A worked campaign example
Worked campaign angle for Brief A: the failed fix, explained, as a mini VSL test.
1. Define the test. One product, one cold-audience persona, one primary measure: new-customer acquisition cost. Strip retargeting purchases out of reporting and agree how incrementality will be checked. Do not accept blended ROAS as the success metric.
2. Gather inputs before writing. Pull ad account metrics, customer reviews, ad comments and survey data. Collect product ingredient evidence and the competitor landscape. For a collagen-style product, Yanko's example uses four inputs: ad account, product ingredients, competitor landscape and personas, then builds the persona from what buyers actually said and did, not assumptions.
3. Write the argument in three acts. Act one: the science of the problem, such as collagen dropping around 30% in the first five years of menopause in their example. Act two: the science of what the buyer has already tried and why it was never going to work, such as underdosed powders and peptides too large to absorb. Act three: the solution mechanism, a peptide small enough to absorb at the dose used in studies. Add proof from buyers of the same age or life stage. Keep that order. Their posts say these three sections do 80-90% of the work in winning mini VSLs, and that explaining the problem makes earlier purchases look like dead ends and the new mechanism like the only logical answer.
4. Choose format after argument. Produce several mini VSL concepts, two to five minutes each, with talking heads and split-screen B-roll. Do not start with format. Once one wins, iterate it with different formats, personas or messaging.
5. Add the AI search layer. Before the test, run category prompts in ChatGPT or similar tools and record which brands appear. Run the same prompts after the campaign. Recruit creators through an affiliate programme to publish reviews, comparisons, tutorials and testimonials on the platforms AI systems draw from: blogs, YouTube, TikTok, podcasts and reviews. Track brand mention volume alongside direct-response metrics. Treat this as mention-building, not just conversion.
6. Ask before signing. Request recent comparable cold-traffic results from the last six months. Ask how the creator pipeline is staffed, what response times creators get, and whether deliverables arrive as scripts and briefs or as managed production. Ask who owns any AI-assisted process and how the brand's context is maintained. If the answers are thin, keep the test small and hold the budget until the first creative readout.
Before a large spend, ask for actual ad files, transcripts, campaign performance and independent client results, which their posts do not include. The angle above is built from the method described in their posts and should be validated against current comparable results.